Hollow Middle

Lately, there has been a lot of discussion about AI making knowledge workers more efficient. Deploying AI to accomplish task-level administrative work, routine analysis, writing and design work, which means eliminating many of the entry level jobs.  The implication is that businesses will need fewer employees to accomplish the same work, and therefore lower payroll expenses and greater profitability.

Individuals fresh out of school with limited experience used to enter a sort of apprenticeship in their first job. They were assigned the grunt work to do research and write reports and make slide presentations in support of more experienced supervisors and managers. They made mistakes and reached erroneous conclusions. Their papers were badly written or poorly argued, and their slides were clumsy. But, their experienced supervisors oversaw the work, made corrections and taught the entry-level workers how to improve. In time, they built up their business muscles, and their work output improved as they gained experience and matured. In the business meritocracy, they moved up the ranks, and the next group of recent grads came in below them.

Mid-level supervisors gained their experience by once being entry-level employees. Their time in the cellar taught them what good looks like, and in our current AI revolution, it has equipped them to effectively guide their AI partner to do the grunt work for them. In time, they will progress in their careers and move further up the ladder, and here is where the problem begins. If AI eliminates the entry level apprentice roles, then there are no entry-level people gaining experience, and once the experienced mid-level folks move up, who will take their place? Individuals fresh out of school cannot jump into the mid-level roles without experience, but the jobs where they traditionally would gain experience have been eliminated. The middle is being hollowed out, or at least that is how the argument goes.

For many individuals seeking their first job, the market is challenging, and the sentiment about the elimination of entry-level positions is absolutely valid. However, I had an experience last week that challenged how I was thinking about the problem. I had assumed that the higher-education system had remained static, and colleges and universities were turning out students with similar skills and knowledge to the students that graduated five or ten years ago. Based on that assumption, I concluded the education system was the culprit not preparing students for the new job market. What I was missing is that college students today were not only born digital and totally comfortable with their apps and devices, they also are increasingly AI natives who have matured right along with AI tools. Unlike their predecessors who are AI immigrants new to the land of AI, the current cadre has been using AI tools for years, honing their skills at applying AI to do incredible things.

Recently, while attending a CEO forum at a major university, the professor leading the forum introduced us to an undergraduate senior in the business and engineering schools. This impressive individual has been developing applications of AI for quite some time. Two weeks before the forum, the professor challenged him to create a CRM-like tool and present it to a bunch of CEOs. What he built was astonishing. It was simple to use, and robust. It integrated with multiple systems and social sites to manage current customer records, prospect for new customers, draft marketing messages and manage multi-step conditional campaigns. It monitored prospects’ digital behaviors and highlighted buying signals and crafted appropriate outreach assets. In short, in a couple of weeks, this college senior studied the current state of CRM products, designed and created a thoughtful competitive offering and made it into a functioning application all by himself, with no coding, just an AI partner. Every CEO in the room wanted to hire this guy. 

The professor admitted that this individual is a bit exceptional, but claimed there were several hundred more students right behind him that are similarly capable. As these students graduate and enter the job market, they will be equipped to contribute in a manner far beyond what was historically an entry-level skill set. With their AI-native skills, they mastered the grunt work years ago. They will still need a supervisor to help them adapt to the specifics of their new employer, but their raw talent will propel them to be able to contribute in weeks or months, rather than years. 

What is even more exciting is that many of these young adults are choosing entrepreneurship instead of traditional entry-level jobs. When they see a business opportunity, their native-AI skills enable them to rapidly build a solution with minimal capital. They can easily experiment, launch businesses, and adapt solutions to meet market needs. The CRM demo we saw was easily the equivalent of the major functions of legacy products that took years to create with thousands of engineering hours and millions of dollars invested, and it was built by one person in a couple of weeks with essentially free AI tools.

Instead of a hollowing out of qualified individuals for middle-level supervisor roles, we may see a generational transformation of the entire HR hierarchy. Entry-level AI-native employees may eliminate multiple levels of more senior positions. They will increasingly enter the business world as founders and CEOs instead of employees. Rather than needing an apprenticeship to learn the basics, they will need coaches and mentors to help them build leadership and managerial skills. The experience they are lacking is how to build and scale a businesses, but speed and agility will be their disrupter as they compete with flat-footed traditional businesses.